In my ongoing quest to reduce my comma usage I've decided to look up semicolons.

[conuly]

On one hand, using semicolons instead of commas when either would do would absolutely reduce the number of commas in my writing.

On the other hand, I'd then look like the sort of dweeb who uses semicolons on reddit. And when I say I'd look that way, I mean I'd absolutely be that way. Plus, would I really be accomplishing anything besides fooling myself? What I really need to do is either a. let it go or b. start rewriting my sentences to be comma-free, ideally without making them choppy.

Hm.

Is it possible I want too much? Are all these goals actually achievable at the same time?

***********************

The Outsiders: The letter that inspired a cult classic

China showcases its first lightweight lunar spacesuit designed for 2030 moon landing

Black hole shot a beam through space. NASA snapped stunning footage.

Spanish mother and daughter train bacteria to restore church frescoes

Port strikes end with deal on wages, averting economic disaster

‘I am going to die’: North Dakota teen in runaway vehicle saved by crashing into police car

Newsom vetoes bill that would have required speed-limit alert systems in new cars

Millions depend on the Mississippi—but the mighty river is running dry

Far right wins close Austria election, a boost for Putin

Switzerland and Italy redraw border due to melting glaciers

Helene’s powerful storm surge killed 12 near Tampa. They didn’t have to die

Comments

[steepholm]

What's wrong with semicolons on Reddit? Better a dweeb than a comma-splicing oaf!

[conuly]

I don't think I do splice my commas. I just think I use them too much.

[steepholm]

I'm sure you don't! I'm just shaking my fist at an imaginary cloud composed of all my comma-splicing students.

[greenwoodside]

I thought by and large semi-colons replaced full stops rather than commas?

(Except when separating items on a long list, where some of the items themselves are long enough to need commas, so semi-colons are added for clarity. Though I guess in most situations these days that woudn't be an issue – for writing online I'd use bullet points.)

[greenwoodside]

Sorry, imagine the above said in the tones of an anxious semi-trained web editor who's having sudden Doubts About Punctuation.

Like a crisis of religious belief, but happening in middle age and possibly more traumatic.

[redbird]

I use a lot of semi-colons, especially when I realize that I have a long sentence, full of commas. Then I sometimes go back, and change semi-colons to periods. Also, as you say, they're useful for lists. (I remember seeing an example like "people came from New York City; Newark, N.J.; Washington, D.C.; and Moscow, Idaho," whereas the list "Boston, New York, Philadelphia, and Chicago" gets commas.)

Formally, you're supposed to use semi-colons for things that could be separate sentences, and commas otherwise. The sentence above doesn't have a semi-colon, because "and commas otherwise" doesn't work by itself as a sentence.

That's late-20th and early 21st century usage, and for American English. In works from the 19th century, commas sometimes indicate places where someone speaking would/should pause for breath and/or emphasis.

[brokenallbroken]

This is what I thought too. Perhaps some variety of dash instead?

[malinaldarose]

I have an abundance of semi-colons; I could loan you some.

[moonhare]

I have been using multiple semicolons inn my writing, just because. Anyway, I use lots of commas, too, because I tend to write as I think now where I pause a lot or invert ideas.

Long sentences? Read some of these!
link removed

[gingicat]

Semicolons are one of my favorite things, but I'm also not a Redditor. (And a semicolon could not have replaced that comma.)

[chazzbanner]

I love semi-colons! I probably use them too much, but I'm unrepentant.

I love a comment I read in a review an Aubrey-Maturin novel: "O'Brian has the wittiest semi-colons since Jane Austen." Of course not everyone uses them as a stylistic device. :-)

[malada]

Punctuation matters.

Plot matters more.

[cellio]

Commas and semicolons are both important tools. They're usually tools for different things; I don't think of them as trading off against each other.