While reading fanfic, it occurs to me that the correct answer to

[conuly]

"Potter, where would you look if I told you to find me a bezoar?" is "Probably the supply cabinet."

I mean, does Snape expect him to slaughter a goat right there in the classroom? (You don't need to tell me that pointing this out would not have helped.)

Bezoars are real, by the way, though we've known for a very long time that they don't cure poison.

**********

More palindromes in video form

So Much Cooking (Fiction, food blogging during an epidemic)

The Past and the Future of the Earth’s Oldest Trees

Four 100-year-old World War II veterans will participate in the Super Bowl coin toss (Why exactly is the NFL so entangled with the US military, though?)

FDA approves first treatment for kids with peanut allergy

Why you shouldn’t obsess about “overpopulation”

Congress Moves to Restrict Trump’s War Powers, Repeal 17-Year Iraq War Authorization

More and more students are experiencing homelessness, according to new federal data

Friends don’t let friends lie about having cancer.

The Craigslist of Guns

Comments

[rhoda_rants]

I mean, does Snape expect him to slaughter a goat right there in the classroom? (You don't need to tell me that pointing this out would not have helped.)
Okay, I kinda wanna see someone write that scene now, just to see how he'd respond to that level of Sass.

[conuly]

Five points from Gryffindor for excessive mirth!

[roselightfairy]

1) You make an excellent point.
2) Had Harry not gone with his chosen delivery of sass, he honestly would probably say this, and it cracks me up because your point is both practical and in-character.

[conuly]

Hermione, meanwhile, doesn't understand why this answer is correct and "stomach of a goat" is wholly impractical.

[gingicat]

The cancer story reminds me of someone in alt.callahans in the early 90s who went by the nick DidiSprite.

[conuly]

It's hard to have sympathy for people who do this.

[gingicat]

Oh, I will always remember her with anger. I was thankfully not one of her victims, but what she did to others...

[alexseanchai]

I have seen that answer in a fic, but the fic I thought it was (Harry Potter and the Nightmares of Futures Past) turns out to not be it…

[conuly]

Link if you find it, will you?

[alexseanchai]

"Miss Mayeux, where would I look to find a bezoar?"

"In that cabinet, third shelf, on the left in the wicker basket," said the black girl, pointing at the smaller of the supply cabinets.

"I meant in its natural state, Miss Mayeux," Snape said with gritted teeth.

"You should have said so," the girl responded with the same slightly absent tone that the Lovegood girl used when she was at her most aggravating. "You'd find it in the stomach of an ibex or goat, of course. Or in the stomach of a sheep, but the quality isn't nearly as good."

—Ishtar, many chapters into Harry Potter and the Junior Year Abroad

[conuly]

Honestly, Snape, what did you expect?

[alexseanchai]

for context, these are sixteen-year-old exchange students he's quizzing, using the same set of questions he canonically gave eleven-year-olds in their first lesson, so even before we get to the parts blatantly criticizing Snape as a teacher and as someone who keeps up on outside-UK advances in his field…

[moon_custafer]

Now I kind of want a “think of ponies before zebras” teacher who’s trying to get the students to give the pragmatic rather than the textbook answer, and who snaps “and if I asked you for a match, would you go cut down a tree?” at the first one who confidently replies “the stomach of a goat.”

[oursin]

Thought for a medievalish murder mystery - the bezoar itself was poisoned!!!! - though they must have been seething horrors of bacteriological nightmare, not to mention assorted allergens, even when they didn't contain mercury....

[conuly]

Though if you've actually been poisoned that's probably the least of your worries.

[greghousesgf]

The author of the overpopulation article makes a very odd assumption. I have no intention of having children but neither do I intend on ever driving to Peru.