Curious Incident?
Aug. 28th, 2006 11:48 pmRemember that book? That lovely piece of fiction? Written by somebody who is not autistic?
Yeah, that.
It isn't a good reference material. For anybody. Because the person writing the book lacked any sort of personal experience with autism. And it's fiction. FICTION.
There are scads of autistic authors out there. Some of them are quite well-known. (And, to head off this argument, if you want to know how autistic people think, you really would want to read works by more than one autistic person, because not all autistics think the same way.)
Now, go forth and educate yourself.
Thank you.
Yeah, that.
It isn't a good reference material. For anybody. Because the person writing the book lacked any sort of personal experience with autism. And it's fiction. FICTION.
There are scads of autistic authors out there. Some of them are quite well-known. (And, to head off this argument, if you want to know how autistic people think, you really would want to read works by more than one autistic person, because not all autistics think the same way.)
Now, go forth and educate yourself.
Thank you.
no subject
Date: 2006-08-29 10:49 pm (UTC)After I finished it, I was really curious how well people thought it actually represented autism, and couldn't find much in the way of answers. But I hope it's a bad fit, because the main character isn't at all likable. Well, he is, at first. But as it progresses, he becomes less and less likable. And I don't want to think of people I know on the spectrum as being like him. Fortunately, I don't.
I think it was intended to create a greater acceptance and sympathy for the autistic. To help NTs realize that their behaviors aren't bad, just different. But it completely fails by making the main character completely and utterly self-absorbed and selfish.
no subject
Date: 2006-08-30 10:22 am (UTC)Just out of curiosity, I'm wondering what you meant. Is the audiobook format only available by special order to those who are blind/print-disabled? Do you have to go through a doctor to get a prescrition in order to get it?
Or are you saying that someone has to be blind/print-disabled in order to enjoy and appreciate audiobooks?
Because I know a good number of people with perfectly decent vision, who read print books by the dozens, and love audiobooks and oftentimes listen to them while walking or on long commutes.
I can't, for obvious reasons, being deaf, but still... I've been sitting here trying to figure out what exactly you meant there.
no subject
Date: 2006-08-30 05:11 pm (UTC)I have no idea how similar or different any other audiobook version of the book may be. Perhaps sometimes it is the same, but it could be done by someone completely different, and my guess is it is. So, you can't listen to the version I heard unless you're in the program (and can hear).