Okay, my reconstructed list so far....

[conuly]

A - toy ant, or apple, or alligator. (I want to minimize this sort of thing if I can.)
B - small blocks, or balls, or (jingle) bells, or buttons
C - cardboard pieces, or small (toy) cups, or cotton balls, or coins, or crayons, or candles
Ch (why not separate it, after all) -
D - small dolls
E - a blown-out or plastic egg
F - feathers, or felt
G - (cheap sun)glasses
H - crochet hooks
I -
J - jacks, or small jars
K - keys
L - lambs wool, or lace, or magnetic letters (ls, of course), or leaves
M - marbles, or metrocards
N - nailclippers
O - uncooked oatmeal
P - paper clips, or puzzle pieces, or pipe cleaners, or uncooked pasta
Q - quilt scraps (by which I mean a small bit of cloth with something appliqued on it. It's a stretch)
R - rocks, or ribbons, or uncooked rice
S - sandpaper? or straws, or scrunchies
Sh - shoelaces, or shells
T - tea bags, or
Th - thimbles
U - little paper umbrellas
V - velvet? or something that velcroes up... just some cloth with velcro on it
W - whistles
X - little toy xes from made tic-tac-toe boards
Y - yarn
Z - zippers

I have more, just... not here. It's at Jenn's.

Comments

[leora.livejournal.com]

Other possibilities:
buttons, hair, nuts, string, tulle (but I don't know a cheap easy way to get it or if I'm spelling it properly... that stuff they sometimes put under dresses to puff them up a bit, I think), toilet paper or tissues

[leora.livejournal.com]

Oh and if you don't use coins then q can be quarters. Or quills if you don't use feathers, but unless you have a quill pen, that's kind of weird. A quiver of arrows would be tricky too.

[ser-kai.livejournal.com]

an orange?

[mayna.livejournal.com]

How about a hat for H? I'm not sure she'll really get crochet hooks. Or a horse figurine (like the plastic ones)
J ... jelly beans
L ... lipstick? lock
N ... nut, nickel
P ... penny
S ... plastic snake, slinky

Some things like the lambs wool, quilt scraps, etc, you'd be having to explain to her that it's a METROcard and not just a card/paper. And she'll probably say sunglasses and not glasses if they're tinted.

[leora.livejournal.com]

Other possibilities:
buttons, hair, nuts, string, tulle (but I don't know a cheap easy way to get it or if I'm spelling it properly... that stuff they sometimes put under dresses to puff them up a bit, I think), toilet paper or tissues

[leora.livejournal.com]

Oh and if you don't use coins then q can be quarters. Or quills if you don't use feathers, but unless you have a quill pen, that's kind of weird. A quiver of arrows would be tricky too.

[ser-kai.livejournal.com]

an orange?

[mayna.livejournal.com]

How about a hat for H? I'm not sure she'll really get crochet hooks. Or a horse figurine (like the plastic ones)
J ... jelly beans
L ... lipstick? lock
N ... nut, nickel
P ... penny
S ... plastic snake, slinky

Some things like the lambs wool, quilt scraps, etc, you'd be having to explain to her that it's a METROcard and not just a card/paper. And she'll probably say sunglasses and not glasses if they're tinted.