Are there muggleborns in Slytherin?
Mar. 26th, 2006 01:24 pmYou'd think there wouldn't be, seeing as how Slytherin was opposed (possibly even for good reasons, read a great fic about that a while back which I should've bookmarked....) to having muggleborns in the school.
But... Slytherin isn't the one deciding who goes where. Everybody believes the hat is. The hat which *Gryffindor* made. (And I, personally, believe that the hat is just confirming the student's own choice as to which house they belong in, but that's another issue.)
The hat only lists "ambition" as the requirement for getting into Slytherin, right? Not some degree of pure blood, that sort of thing...? So couldn't some naive muggleborn who hasn't somehow heard what "all Slytherins are like" think that it's just the place for them?
They'd regret it, but... is it possible?
But... Slytherin isn't the one deciding who goes where. Everybody believes the hat is. The hat which *Gryffindor* made. (And I, personally, believe that the hat is just confirming the student's own choice as to which house they belong in, but that's another issue.)
The hat only lists "ambition" as the requirement for getting into Slytherin, right? Not some degree of pure blood, that sort of thing...? So couldn't some naive muggleborn who hasn't somehow heard what "all Slytherins are like" think that it's just the place for them?
They'd regret it, but... is it possible?
no subject
Date: 2006-03-26 06:38 pm (UTC)*scrolls through*
Okay. He mentions pure-blood fifth year. But, again, Slytherin isn't choosing who goes where, and we know half-bloods have been in Slytherin. What does that mean?
no subject
Date: 2006-03-26 06:44 pm (UTC)But, you know, I could be wrong.