Jun. 12th, 2017

conuly: (Default)
I was an atheist. (And hey, I'm still an atheist!)

But, you know, I had questions about this religion thing. Some extremely vehement atheists are all "Children shouldn't learn about religion at all!", but this strikes me as completely the wrong approach. Most of the world is religious. We have to live with them. Better to give them a fair and even-handed amount of information about all major religions (and a good number of minor ones) so they can come to their own conclusions. You don't want them to conclude you're hiding stuff from them, anyway.

But I digress. I have a point here, not just a soapbox. I asked my mother once about saints in Catholicism. This was logical, because she was raised Catholic, so she really ought to know. And the way she described it to me is that sometimes, you pray to a saint rather than directly to God because it's kind of like asking your parents to talk to the teacher for you. They have a little extra pull, and also, the right saint presumably understands your situation through deep personal experience.

This explanation made perfect sense to me.

Now that I'm grown, though, and know many more Christians and ex-Christians than I did as a child, I wonder if a better explanation here might use the language of prayer circles. Sometimes Christians ask other Christians to pray for them, and Catholics do the same as Protestants, except that sometimes the Christians they're asking to pray for them are saints, not neighbors.

(This is another reason why I actually think all kids should learn comparative religion in school. The level of inter-religious ignorance going around is astounding. "Catholics worship saints!" is actually fairly minor compared to what I heard this weekend, which was 17 flavors of "Muslims worship Mohammed!" I don't have an easy analogy to explain why that last one is absurd, but I'm going to trust that everybody reading this knows it is.)


How to Watch NASA Create Colorful Clouds Over New York and the East Coast

A Clever Technique For Scaling A Wall Using A Bamboo Pole And Two Strong Friends

Growth mechanism of fungi decoded

A slug, a dandelion, a camera

The Baby-Sitters Club Announces Its Intention to Unionize

Lianas stifle tree fruit and seed production in tropical forests

The lost genius of the Post Office

Operation Car Wash: Is this the biggest corruption scandal in history?

Officers at New York precinct told not to shower at station after fears of Legionnaires’ disease (I should take this seriously, and I do! - but I really want to make a joke about dirty cops.)

Russia protests: Kremlin critic Navalny among hundreds detained

Texas's tough pension laws may not apply in other states

D.C. and Maryland to sue President Trump, alleging breach of constitutional oath

Russia cloud settles in over Trump's White House

Donald Trump’s secret isn’t that he lies. It’s that he crowds out the truth.

Trump’s defense against Comey has fallen into a predictable pattern: Make a baseless accusation

'Crash Override': The Malware That Took Down a Power Grid

Missouri parole board played word games during hearings with inmates (How amusing for them.)

Turkey demands an end to Qatar blockade as humanitarian crisis deepens

What if several of the world’s biggest food crops failed at the same time?

Philippines fight against ISIS grinds on, victory still 'weeks' away

Life under martial law in Duterte’s home town

Corpses being dumped in Iraq show signs of torture, execution — and Iraqi forces may be responsible

How a Russian Journalist Exposed the Anti-Gay Crackdown in Chechnya

Rwanda’s children of rape are coming of age — against the odds.

The rising homegrown terror threat on the right


conuly: (Default)

September 2017

      1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 2627 282930

Most Popular Tags

Page Summary

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Sep. 24th, 2017 01:24 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios